Forum Rules and Guidelines Discussion

Just to check I understand - if someone posted details of a precognition experiment (for example) in "Psi Phenomena", and I wanted to say that particular experiment was rubbish, that would be allowed, but if I wanted to say precognition in general was impossible or didn't exist, that should go into Skeptic v Proponent?

Yes and yes.

The prior acceptance of psi phenomena (in your suggested case, ESP) as anomalous* would be required in order to post critical comments in the Psi Phenomena forum. Barring prior acceptance, comments should be posted in the Skeptic v Proponent forum.

*anomalous = unexplained by our current scientific understanding.


Edit: My memory of the current rules has been refreshed. Please read my new position on the matter here:

http://psiencequest.net/forums/thread-15...ml#pid1209