(2019-09-13, 08:39 PM)Laird Wrote: My mistake. I remembered how Bernardo handles this after all: "the redness of red" is "out there" in mind at large, and it "enters the whirlpools" of individual psyches - who then perceive it in turn - via "ripples in the medium of mind" - so they don't need to perceive it directly as malf implied they do, and as I suggested they do. Oops.
Alas, malf - you're on your own again. ;-)
Although the idea that it is (those which I presume to be) the qualia of mind at large which can "ripple in the medium of mind" is in my view an unclear one and is arguably nonsensical, so I might still be with you, malf.