Search Results
    Thread: Trashing natural selection as a special case.
Post: RE: Trashing natural selection as a special case.

stephenw Wrote: (2024-05-04, 10:38 PM) -- Well you have me going in two directions.   Do I defend physicality and the empirical data backing math relations?  Or, the kick in the personals with a chal...
 766     52
    Thread: Trashing natural selection as a special case.
Post: RE: Trashing natural selection as a special case.

nbtruthman Wrote: (2024-05-03, 11:07 PM) -- I would interpret these words as meaning that first, living things perform intelligent information processing. This is obvious for certain living things, n...
 766     52
    Thread: The UFO/UAP coverup continues
Post: RE: The UFO/UAP coverup continues

sbu Wrote: (2024-04-29, 05:47 PM) -- I don’t think the motivation of hiding the development of the nuclear bomb in the middle of world war ii can be compared with the motivation of hiding alien artif...
Posted by Laird in UFOs (and Related) , 2024-04-29, 05:58 PM
 870     65
    Thread: The UFO/UAP coverup continues
Post: RE: The UFO/UAP coverup continues

Brian Wrote: (2024-04-29, 12:22 PM) -- I have noticed that this thread relies upon two conflicting premises. 1. The military can't be trusted - they are obviously covering up. 2. David Grusch and...
Posted by Laird in UFOs (and Related) , 2024-04-29, 03:54 PM
 870     65
    Thread: Trashing natural selection as a special case.
Post: RE: Trashing natural selection as a special case.

stephenw Wrote: (2024-04-27, 03:24 PM) -- I am trying to make my peace with the ideas of Bill Dembski.  My stance is that living things preform information processing that exhibits intelligence.  I m...
 766     52
    Thread: The UFO/UAP coverup continues
Post: RE: The UFO/UAP coverup continues

Brian Wrote: (2024-04-28, 10:12 AM) -- An extremely arrogant assertion followed by justification for wishful thinking. -- As with sbu's reference to "hope", your reference to what I "wish" for is a...
Posted by Laird in UFOs (and Related) , 2024-04-28, 12:25 PM
 870     65
    Thread: The UFO/UAP coverup continues
Post: RE: The UFO/UAP coverup continues

sbu Wrote: (2024-04-28, 08:29 AM) -- In other words, if you are dissatisfied with the world as it is, you can pin your hopes on future discoveries, such as faster-than-light travel, that might change...
Posted by Laird in UFOs (and Related) , 2024-04-28, 12:24 PM
 870     65
    Thread: Reddit's latest NDE thread: claims of EEG being unreliable to detect activity
Post: RE: Reddit's latest NDE thread: claims of EEG bein...

Quote: -- Sam Parnia is being referred to as a "woo peddler" -- So? You meet all sorts of people if you wander around corners of the internet.
Posted by Typoz in Skeptic vs. Proponent Discussions , 2024-04-27, 10:03 PM
 165     7
    Thread: The UFO/UAP coverup continues
Post: RE: The UFO/UAP coverup continues

sbu Wrote: (2024-04-27, 04:42 PM) -- Do you have any hard facts like radar data to suggest it wasn’t a balloon? -- Yes. For example, from the article: Quote: -- In one bizarre incident, a Neb...
Posted by Laird in UFOs (and Related) , 2024-04-27, 04:51 PM
 870     65
    Thread: The UFO/UAP coverup continues
Post: RE: The UFO/UAP coverup continues

sbu Wrote: (2024-04-27, 02:17 PM) -- This claim might simply involve a balloon with a flashlight, possibly part of a high school experiment. It reminds me of the balloons that were shot down by F-22s...
Posted by Laird in UFOs (and Related) , 2024-04-27, 03:50 PM
 870     65
    Thread: Trashing natural selection as a special case.
Post: RE: Trashing natural selection as a special case.

stephenw Wrote: (2024-04-25, 08:54 PM) -- I would describe mind as an abstraction referring to information processing.  -- The trouble with that, is that you can either define information as Shannon ...
 766     52
    Thread: After-Death Communications: New Cases That Bear on the Question of Survival
Post: RE: After-Death Communications: New Cases That Bea...

I guess it may depend on what he means by “intrinsically subjective”. If there are veridical elements, I suppose the experience of them is subjective  but the information would be objective wouldn’t i...
 160     5
    Thread: Trashing natural selection as a special case.
Post: RE: Trashing natural selection as a special case.

stephenw Wrote: (2024-04-25, 07:34 PM) -- This is a thread pointing to actual prominent thinkers and researchers explaining in detail how RM + NS don't work.  I don't get how you come back with a neg...
 766     52
    Thread: Trashing natural selection as a special case.
Post: RE: Trashing natural selection as a special case.

sbu Wrote: (2024-04-24, 12:53 PM) -- You know that I completely disagree with the notion of 'proof' when using this argument. A proof is a logical argument that demonstrates that a proposition is tru...
 766     52
    Thread: Trashing natural selection as a special case.
Post: RE: Trashing natural selection as a special case.

Quote: -- "Life is achingly beautiful and creative once you free yourself from the mind-numbing shackles of neo-Darwinian dogma." -- Mae Wan Ho https://www.thethirdwayofevolution.com/peopl...
 766     52
    Thread: After-Death Communications: New Cases That Bear on the Question of Survival
Post: After-Death Communications: New Cases That Bear on...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D5ZhEsWoQnc Quote: -- Abstract: A spontaneous After-Death Communication (ADC) occurs when a bereaved person unexpectedly perceives the deceased person. This ma...
 160     5
    Thread: Trashing natural selection as a special case.
Post: RE: Trashing natural selection as a special case.

I'd like to expand a little about the idea of Complex Specified Information (CSI). Typically we think of CSI as the information contained in protein-coding DNA. However try not to think of that as a l...
 766     52
    Thread: Trashing natural selection as a special case.
Post: RE: Trashing natural selection as a special case.

nbtruthman Wrote: (2024-04-18, 07:16 PM) -- As for Complex Specified Information (CSI) according to Dembski, I basically agree with his definition, it being "...an "explanatory filter": one can recog...
 766     52
    Thread: The evidence for strong emergence in chemistry
Post: RE: The evidence for strong emergence in chemistry

sbu Wrote: (2024-04-21, 05:30 PM) -- For me, the improbability of RM+NS producing complex systems like human biology doesn't necessarily imply direct evidence for discarnate entities. A plausible nat...
 505     27
    Thread: The evidence for strong emergence in chemistry
Post: RE: The evidence for strong emergence in chemistry

sbu Wrote: (2024-04-18, 09:48 PM) -- I believe I can succinctly summarize your message as follows: 'Since human DNA couldn’t have evolved by chance, there must be a greater meaning.' It’s a compellin...
 505     27