(2017-10-10, 04:23 PM)tim Wrote: Are you trying to suggest that Parnia didn't say that or I'm making up crap ?
The article doesn't directly quote Parnia on reflexes during CPR. It is an indirect quote. Did Parnia actually say "reflexes don't resume during CPR."? We will never know unless we contact the author of the article and request a transcript. I seriously doubt he would say that given the fact that there are a couple of seemingly conclusive studies that state the exact opposite, one of them appearing I believe in Resuscitation Journal, which one could assume Parnia might read.
I don't think you are making up the fact that the article provides an indirect quote of Parnia saying that. I am suggesting that Parnia didn't use those exact words, especially since many actual quotes appear in the article and the bit about reflexes is not a direct quote.
Why is it such a big deal to you if reflexes occur during some cases of cardiac arrest and CPR? Who cares?
Do you think accuracy isn't important when discussing these topics?