"Why I am no longer a skeptic"

The links should be in order.

I wasn't claiming anything about anybody's sensory state, because we don't know anybody's sensory state in those cases. I just wanted to make the point that whether or not the cases are remarkable depends upon the individual's sensory state, and we don't know what that is. Whereas a hidden target is remarkable regardless of anybody's (unknown) sensory states.

However, research looking, for example, at learning while under anesthesia, shows us that we shouldn't be making assumptions about what people can't do while unconsciousness.

Linda

Thanks I'll check them out!

We don't know for sure, but we have a good idea based on the fact they were receiving CPR etc, so their sensory state according to our current knowledge should be non existent, if not at least hugely impaired.

We shouldn't make assumptions, so why did you tell me you could hear 60 feet away as if that means Anita (sorry if wrong name) could? It has no bearing because as you said - we don't truly know their sensory states.