Life with purpose

.............................
Even if one were to accept this argument that Darwinism => Nihilism, it's the consequentialist fallacy - that something has to be false because the implications of it being true are too awful to accept. 
.............................

Are you saying that one of Darwinism's leading spokesmen, William Provine, was wrong in his much quoted pronouncement? I agree completely that the consequentialist argument is fallacious, but I never made that argument, I merely pointed out the inevitable implications.