Consciousness restored in man after 15 years in vegetative state

72 Replies, 11343 Views

(2017-09-27, 11:25 AM)jkmac Wrote: Just wondering: when does evidence become fact? Does it ever?

If a witness of a murder says: "a slender tall white man walked up and shot the guy in the chest".

That's testimonial evidence right?

After a second witness corroborates the story, is it still evidence? or fact?

After a third?

What happens when a police officer says, yes I saw that too?

Do these confirming stories EVER become considered "fact"?

I guess it is a probability assessment. It's a good question - what is a 100% nailed on fact? Perhaps only when we experience it ourselves directly. In which case Steve's (probably - geddit?) wasting his time.
[-] The following 1 user Likes Obiwan's post:
  • The King in the North
(2017-09-26, 09:39 PM)tim Wrote: Where was the emotion ? Madeleine Lawrence carried out a study into coma patients. That's it. What they reported is what they reported.

 https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=RM0h...ts&f=false

That looks interesting tim - I am having difficulty locating the book/author on amazon.
[-] The following 1 user Likes Obiwan's post:
  • tim
(2017-09-27, 11:55 AM)Obiwan Wrote: That looks interesting tim - I am having difficulty locating the book/author on amazon.

Yes I struggled to find it again myself but here it is.

https://www.amazon.com/World-Their-Own-M...0897896505
[-] The following 2 users Like tim's post:
  • Doug, Obiwan
Thanks tim.
[-] The following 1 user Likes Obiwan's post:
  • tim
(2017-09-27, 11:12 AM)Steve001 Wrote: We have different definitions of that word. In all my decades to listening to people that believe,  I've not ever heard of one fact being stated. No, I don't care to read testimonials.

You can't be serious ?
[-] The following 1 user Likes tim's post:
  • The King in the North
(2017-09-27, 12:10 PM)tim Wrote: You can't be serious ?

Sadly I think he is. I don't know what would constitute a fact simply being stated. It's a fact that I think that... can't prove it as a fact for you. 
I wouldn't waste too much energy.
[-] The following 3 users Like Obiwan's post:
  • tim, The King in the North, Doug
(2017-09-27, 12:02 PM)tim Wrote: Yes I struggled to find it again myself but here it is.

https://www.amazon.com/World-Their-Own-M...0897896505

Pricey but worth a punt.
(2017-09-27, 12:19 PM)Obiwan Wrote: Pricey but worth a punt.

It depends on what interests you, Obiwan. I liked it, it's in the attic now but from memory there are some interesting stories in there. I don't want to "sell" you (persuade you) the book and then you buy it and be disappointed. If you can get it for a few pounds I'd say go for it but not if you have to pay 20 pounds or so.
[-] The following 1 user Likes tim's post:
  • Obiwan
(2017-09-27, 12:14 PM)Obiwan Wrote: Sadly I think he is. I don't know what would constitute a fact simply being stated. It's a fact that I think that... can't prove it as a fact for you. 
I wouldn't waste too much energy.

Okay, got you, Obiwan.
Madeleine has a website here. She takes her work very seriously, she deals in "facts" all the time. There's no doubt that people have NDE's (fact) and no doubt that they have the perception of seeing their physical bodies (fact ref Blackmore).

 http://www.madelainelawrence.com/


Since 1975 when Raymond Moody's book, Life after Life, was published a wonderful journey of discovery began about not only near-death experiences but also many other transpersonal experiences surrounding death.  That's not to say these experiences weren't described before.  Michael Tymn's book, The Afterlife Explorers (Volume 1): The Pioneers of Psychical Research, describes well the early efforts of researchers interested in psychic phenomena.

Research in the 1970s in psychic and transpersonal experiences shifted from the study of the psychically gifted, but sometimes fraudulent, to healthcare patients.  From then on the research involved more stringent methods with unbiased patients as subjects, as surprised as anyone that these experiences had occurred to them.

The research remains in healthcare facilities like acute care hospitals and hospice.  I believe it is time to enhance that focus.  The research techniques we have learned to use to study these phenomena should be applied to individuals who are victims of disasters and catastrophic events. 

Unlike doctors and nurses in healthcare facilities the first responders who attend to victims of disasters know little about these transpersonal events.   If a victim reports going out of his or her body and going through a tunnel or seeing deceased friends or relatives, they are likely to be told they have PTSD or some other mental health issue.  That is what we saw happen early on in the study of Near-death experiencers.  

Disaster victims also are not always in their own communities when these events occur.  Some local hospice programs open their bereavement sessions to others who have lost a loved one, even if they were not on the hospice programs.  Disasters victims and their relatives have little support or information about bereavement help.  They most likely would not be told about The International Association of Near-death Experiences (IANDS) where they could get assistance in understanding their near-death experience. 

I am hoping we can see a strong movement toward assisting victims and first responders of disasters to understanding near-death and other transpersonal experiences WHEN they occur to them.  There is no IF they will occur.  The research that has been done points to the likelihood of these events occurring.   My recent article Near-death and other transpersonal experiences during catastrophic events,  has several examples. 

Comments are welcome and encouraged on this topic!
(This post was last modified: 2017-09-27, 12:48 PM by tim.)
[-] The following 3 users Like tim's post:
  • jkmac, Obiwan, Doug

  • View a Printable Version
Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)